70% of S&P 500 Tech Stocks Are Down 20% or More from Their All-Time Highs

Tech stocks continue to be the "anchor tenant" of the S&P 500, with a dominant 37% weighting. That's more than the next three sectors – Financials, Communication Services, and Industrials – combined. In fact, you can even add up the bottom 7 sectors and still not reach the total weighting of tech.

'Shark Tank' Star Kevin O'Leary 'Can't Stand It' When Young People Spend $28 on Lunch But Only Make $70k — 'I Mean, That's Just Stupid'

Broadcom Lands $30 Billion Chip Deal With Apple. Why It's a Win-Win for AAPL and AVGO.

Intel Future Price Hikes Send Huge Demand Signal to Wall Street

Once we take a second to marvel at how well tech investing has done over the years, and the brute force with which its giant companies have taken over the S&P 500 index, there's an issue to address. You see, many of those tech stocks are so big that if they falter, they are likely to take the index down with them.

And right now, 60% of tech stocks are currently in a "bear market" if we use the traditional definition. They are down 20% from their highs. That headline is an attention-grabber.

But I wanted to see if this is one of those skin-deep types of market wounds, or something bigger. Because in my view, if mega-cap tech stocks fall hard and don't get up quickly, it is more likely to be other tech stocks, smaller ones, which pick up the slack.

The whole concept of a "broadening out" trade is frankly lost on me. Why? Because that's what I see in the charts.

The other reason I say this is because of what we see above. For the past three years, the Invesco S&P 500 E.W. Technology ETF (RSPT), which tracks the average tech stock, has performed in line with the SPDR S&P 500 Technology Sector ETF (XLK), the one which has the three-headed monster of Apple (AAPL), Microsoft (MSFT), and Nvidia (NVDA) at the top.

The next few tiers down in market cap size need to be the reinforcements. But all they are doing recently is reinforcing the idea that it's big tech or bust. The aforementioned data point, that 60% of those 70+ tech stocks within the S&P 500 are down at least 20% from their highs, has some uncomfortable roommates in the data point department. Here they are:

70% of those S&P 500 tech stocks are down more than 20% from their all-time highs, and half of those are off at least 35%.

Over the past five years, every one of those 72 stocks has had a decline of at least 27%. More than half have lost at least 50% of their value at some point during the past five years.

One out of four have lost at least two-thirds of their peak value at some point during that same 5-year period.

Taken together, that paints a picture of the sector, and by association a stock market, which is hanging on by a thread. That's not a healthy market. And while this SPY chart is more indicative of a market still trying to grapple with this, as opposed to letting go and tanking, that latter scenario is increasing in likelihood.

XLK's chart, which of course is biased heavily toward the biggest names in the sector, has a clear message. As I read it, it has already moved one step further down the road of reversing its more-than-50% trough-to-peak move since just over three months ago. The bigger they rise, the harder they fall?

The "bailout" for tech here would be if there was a better technical picture by smoothing the weights, and viewing it via RSPT, which is an equal-weight S&P 500 tech stock index ETF. But it looks nearly identical to XLK.

This extreme split comes down to a direct divergence in how institutional money is moving. Big money desks are treating tech like a zero-sum game. They are aggressively pulling cash out of everyday software, networking, and secondary tech stocks, and piling all of it into the absolute best growth spots in the semiconductor hardware space.